Journal of Islamic Law Research

Journal of Islamic Law Research

Validity of Heirs’ Dispositions of the Estate Before the Settlement of the Decedent’s Debts: Reflections in Islamic Law

Type : Research Article

Author
Javad Niknejad
Associate Professor, Department of Private Law, Faculty of Humanities, West Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
10.30497/law.2026.249171.3887
Abstract
 ‌Context & Objective: Upon a person's death the estate's ownership transfers to the heirs under Islamic and Iranian law yet Article 868 of the Civil Code stipulates that this ownership remains unsettled until the decedent’s debts are paid. This article explores the status of transactions conducted by heirs regarding estate assets before such settlement. The research focuses on whether these dispositions are void unratified or valid under a specific legal condition known as Mora’a. The primary objective is to clarify the jurisprudential and legal framework surrounding these transactions to resolve ambiguities within Imami jurisprudence and the Iranian legal system.
 ‌Method & Approach: The study employs a doctrinal legal methodology characterized by a comprehensive analysis of classical and contemporary Islamic legal texts and Iranian statutes. The researcher examines the opinions of prominent Imami jurists and legal scholars through a descriptive-analytical approach. The discussion is structured to evaluate the nature of heirs' ownership before debt settlement followed by an analysis of the validity and legal effects of their dispositions through a critical review of existing theories such as suspended non-ratification and Mora’a status.
 ‌Findings: The research finds that heirs’ ownership is immediate upon death but remains in a state of Mora’a or instability. It critiques the theory of suspended non-ratification (Mowquf) by noting that debt payment automatically validates the contract without requiring further permission from creditors. Furthermore, the article rejects the notion that Mora’a is an independent legal status between validity and voidness. Instead, the findings suggest that transactions by heirs are initially valid but remain subject to the creditors’ prior rights which act as a potential legal barrier. The article demonstrates that Unification Judgment No. 832 of the Supreme Court of Iran supports the validity and immediate legal effect of such conditional transactions.
 ‌Conclusion: The article concludes that transactions by heirs regarding the estate before debt settlement are valid but subject to automatic dissolution (Inifisakh) if creditors exercise their rights. If the debt is paid or waived the transaction remains fully effective. However, if the debt exceeds the estate and covers its benefits the dissolution is retroactive whereas it is prospective if the estate assets are sufficient to cover liabilities. This legal interpretation is grounded in the Rule of No Harm (La Darar) the principle of implicit constructive conditions and the legal succession of the transferee. This approach balances the interests of heirs creditors and bona fide third-party purchasers while promoting the efficient circulation of wealth.
Keywords
Mora'a Ownership
Unratified Contract
State of Non-Ratification
Automatic Dissolution
Subjects
  1. Amid, Mousa (1342 SH/1963). Erṯ dar Ḥoqūq-e Madanī-ye Īrān [Inheritance in Iranian Civil Law] (1st ed.). Tehran: Library of Majlis Council [in Persian].
  2. Amili Jaba'i (Shahid-e Sani), Zain al-Din ibn Ali ibn Ahmad (n.d.). Masālik al-afhām ilā tanqīḥ Šarāʾiʿ al-Eslām (Vol. 14, 1st ed.). Qom: Islamic Knowledge Institute [in Arabic].
  3. Amili Jazini (Shahid-e Awwal), Abu Abdallah Shams al-Din Mohammad ibn Makki ibn Mohammad (n.d.). al-Durūs al-šarʿīyah fī feqh al-Emāmīyah (Vol. 2, 1st ed.). Qom: Islamic Publications Office [in Arabic].
  4. Bahr al-Ulum, Sayyid Mohammad ibn Sayyid Mohammad Taqi (1403 AH/1983). Bulaġat al-faqīh (Vol. 4, 4th ed.). Tehran: Maktabat al-Sadiq [in Arabic].
  5. Bahrami, Ehsan (1401 SH/2022). ʿUdūl az Qāʿideh-ye Ṣalāḥīyat-e Maḥallī va Ġayr-e Qābel-e Ebṭāl Būdan-e Ḥokm-e Dādgāh dar Daʿvā-ye Taqsaīm-e Tarekeh [Deviation from the Rule of Territorial Jurisdiction and Non-Revocability of Court Judgment in Estate Division Lawsuit]. Pazhoheshhay-e Hoquqi [Law Research Magazine], Vol. 21, No. 49. doi: 10.48300/jlr.2022.148307 [in Persian].
  6. Emami, Sayyid Hasan (1392 SH/2013). Ḥoqūq-e Madanī [Civil Law] (Vol. 2, 20th ed.). Tehran: Islamiyah [in Persian].
  7. Esmaeili, Mohsen, & Tavakoli Kia, Saeed (1390 SH/2011). Šarṭ-e Ertekāzī dar Feqh-e Emāmīyeh va Ḥoqūq-e Īrān [Mentally Established Conditions in the Shia Jurisprudence and the Law of Iran]. Pazhoheshnameh-ye Hoquq-e Eslami [Journal of Islamic Law Research], Vol. 12, No. 2. doi: 10.30497/law.2012.1031 [in Persian].
  8. Fallahi, Azad, & Fallahi, Farzad (1399 SH/2020). Neqarešī-ye Now bar Muʿāmaleh-ye Rāhin Nesbat beh ʿAyn-e Marhūneh [A New Perspective on Mortgagor's Transaction Regarding Mortgaged Property]. Faslnameh-ye Tahqiqat-e Hoquq-e Khososi va Keyfari [Private and Criminal Law Research Quarterly], Vol. 16, No. 43 [in Persian].
  9. Fazel Hindi, Mohammad ibn Hasan (n.d.). Kašf al-liṯām va al-ibhām ʿan Qavāʿid al-aḥkām (Vol. 9, 1st ed.). Qom: Islamic Publications Office [in Arabic].
  10. Ghabooli Dorafešan, Sayyid Mohammad Mehdi, & Ghabooli Dorafešan, Sayyid Mohammad Hadi (1392 SH/2013). Barresī-ye Feqhī-Ḥoqūqī-ye Tarekeh Pas az Fowt-e Motavaffā [Jurisprudential-Legal Analysis of the Estate after the Deceased's Death]. Majalleh-ye Molate'at-e Hoquq-e Tatbiqi-ye Mo'aser [Contemporary Comparative Law Studies Journal], Vol. 4, No. 7 [in Persian].
  11. Hilli (Allamah), Hasan ibn Yousuf (1413 AH/1992). Qavāʿid al-aḥkām (Vols. 2 & 3, 1st ed.). Qom: Islamic Publications Office [in Arabic].
  12. Hilli (Fakhr al-Muhaqqiqin), Abu Talib Mohammad ibn al-Hasan ibn Yousuf ibn al-Mutahhar (1387 AH/1967). Ī̇ḍāḥ al-favāʾid fī šarḥ iškālāt al-Qavāʿid (Vol. 2, 1st ed.). Qom: Al-Matba'at al-Ilmiyah [in Arabic].
  13. Hilli (Muhaqqiq), Najm al-Din Jafar ibn Hasan (1408 AH/1987). Šarāʾiʿ al-Eslām fī masāʾil al-ḥalāl va al-ḥarām (Vol. 4, 2nd ed.). Qom: Ismāʿīlīyān Institute [in Arabic].
  14. Hilli, Ibn Idris (1410 AH/1989). al-Sarāʾir al-ḥāwī li-taḥrīr al-fatāwī (Vol. 2, 2nd ed.). Qom: Islamic Publications Office [in Arabic].
  15. Hosseini Amili, Sayyid Mohammad Javad (n.d.). Miftāḥ al-karāmah fī šarḥ Qavāʿid al-ʿAllāmah (Vol. 15). Qom: Islamic Publications Office [in Arabic].
  16. Javaherkalam, Mohammad Hadi (1401 SH/2022). Aṯar-e Fasḵ-e Qarārdād-e Noḵost bar Muʿāmalāt-e Baʿdī [Effect of Rescinding the First Contract on Subsequent Transactions]. Majalleh-ye Naqd va Taḥlīl-e Ārāʾ-ye Qażāyī [Judicial Opinions Critique and Analysis Journal], Vol. 1, No. 2. doi: 10.22034/analysis.2023.701507 [in Persian].
  17. Javaherkalam, Mohammad Hadi (1402 SH/2023). Vażʿīyat-e Taṣarrofāt-e Muntaqil-ʿAlayh dar Zamān-e Ḵiyār-e Nāqil dar Ḥoqūq-e Eslāmī [The Status of Transferee's Possessions during the Transferor's Option Period in Islamic Law]. Pazhoheshhay-e Hoquq-e Eqtesadi va Tejari [Economic and Commercial Law Research], Vol. 1, No. 1. doi: 10.48308/eclr.2023.103068 [in Persian].
  18. Karimi, Abbas (1391 SH/2012). Talāšī barāye Sāmāndehī-ye Naẓarīyeh-ye ʿAdam-e Nofūẕ-e Morāʿā [An Attempt to Organize the Theory of Pending Unenforceability]. Faslnameh-ye Didgah-hay-e Hoquq-e Qazayi [Judicial Law Views Quarterly], Vol. 17, No. 58 [in Persian].
  19. Karimi, Abbas, & Ebrahimi, Davoud (1401 SH/2022). Aʿmāl-e Vażʿīyat-e Ḥoqūqī-ye Morāʿā bar Muʿāmaleh Nesbat beh Māl-e Marhūn [Applying Pending Legal Status to Transactions Concerning Mortgaged Property]. Faslnameh-ye Didgah-hay-e Hoquq-e Qazayi [Judicial Law Views Quarterly], Vol. 27, No. 97 [in Persian].
  20. Karimi, Abbas, & Razi, Sepideh (1399 SH/2020). Muʿāmalāt-e Moʿāreż bā Ḥaqq-e Owlavīyat [Transactions Conflicting with the Right of Priority]. Faslnameh-ye Didgah-hay-e Hoquq-e Qazayi [Judicial Law Views Quarterly], Vol. 25, No. 91 [in Persian].
  21. Karimi, Abbas, & Shabani Kandsari, Hadi (1396 SH/2017). Vażʿīyat-e Ḥoqūqī-ye Morāʿā beh-manzaleh-ye Vażʿīyatī dar ʿArż-e Ṣeḥḥat, Boṭlān va ʿAdam-e Nofūẕ [Pending Legal Status as a Status Alongside Validity, Nullity, and Unenforceability]. Molate'at-e Hoquq-e Khososi [Private Law Studies], Vol. 47, No. 4. doi: 10.22059/jlq.2017.202021.1006717 [in Persian].
  22. Katouzian, Nasser (1388 SH/2009). Qavāʿid-e ʿUmūmī-ye Qarārdādhā [General Rules of Contracts] (Vol. 2, 3rd ed.). Tehran: Enteshar Publishing Company [in Persian].
  23. Katouzian, Nasser (1399 SH/2020). Vaṣīyat dar Ḥoqūq-e Madanī-ye Īrān [Wills in Iranian Civil Law] (2nd ed.). Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh [in Persian].
  24. Katouzian, Nasser (1401 SH/2022). Dars-hā-yī az ʿUqūd-e Moʿayyan [Lessons on Nominate Contracts] (Vol. 1, 31st ed.). Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh [in Persian].
  25. Makarem Shirazi, Naser (1428 AH/2007). al-ʿUrwat al-vuṯqā maʿa al-taʿlīqāt (Vol. 2). Qom: Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib School [in Arabic].
  26. Mawloudi, Mohammad (1383 SH/2004). Qāʾim-maqām-e Ḵāṣṣ-e Mutaʿāqidīn [Specific Successor of the Contracting Parties]. Majalleh-ye Daneshkadeh-ye Hoquq va Olum-e Siyasi-ye Daneshgah-e Tehran [Journal of Faculty of Law and Political Science of Tehran University], No. 64 [in Persian].
  27. Mohaghegh Damad, Sayyid Mustafa, Ghabooli Dorafešan, Sayyid Mohammad Mehdi, & Saatchi, Ali (1394 SH/2015). Taḥlīl-e Vażʿīyat-e Ḥoqūqī-ye Moštarī Nesbat beh Mawred-e Šofʿeh [Analysis of the Legal Status of the Buyer in Relation to the Subject of Preemption]. Majalleh-ye Amoozeh-hay-e Feqh-e Madani [Civil Jurisprudence Doctrines Journal], Vol. 7, No. 11 [in Persian].
  28. Mohaghegh Damad, Seyyed Mostafa, Saatchi, Ali, & Javaherkalam, Mohammad Hadi (1403 SH/2024). Mālekīyat-e Morāʿā; Mafhūm va Maṣādīq [Mora'a Ownership; Definition and Instances]. Pazhoheshnameh-ye Hoquq-e Eslami [Journal of Islamic Law Research], Vol. 25, No. 1. doi: 10.30497/law.2023.243942.3334 [in Persian].
  29. Muqaddas Ardabili, Ahmad ibn Mohammad (n.d.). Zubdat al-bayān fī aḥkām al-Qurʾān (1st ed.). Tehran: Al-Maktabah al-Murtadaviyah [in Arabic].
  30. Najafi, Mohammad Hasan (1362 SH/1983). Javāhir al-kalām fī šarḥ Šarāʾiʿ al-Eslām (Vol. 25). Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi [in Arabic].
  31. Niknejad, Javad (1404 SH/2025). Ṣūrat-bandī-ye Aṯār-e ʿAqd-e Morāʿā dar Feqh-e Emāmīyeh va Ḥoqūq-e Īrān [Formulation of the Effects of the Mora'a Contract in Islamic Law and the Iranian Legal Order]. Pazhoheshnameh-ye Hoquq-e Eslami [Journal of Islamic Law Research], Vol. 26, No. 3. doi: 10.30497/law.2025.247521.3682 [in Persian].
  32. Qomi, Mirza Abu al-Qasim (1413 AH/1992). Jāmiʿ al-šatāt (Vols. 2 & 3, 1st ed.). Tehran: Keyhan Institute [in Persian/Arabic].
  33. Rebati, Mahsa, Mohseni, Saeed, & Ghabooli Dorafešan, Sayyid Mohammad Mehdi (1399 SH/2020). Vākāvī-ye Mafhūm-e Estenādnāpażīrī va Tamāyoz-e Ān az Mafāhīm-e Mošābeh [Analyzing the Concept of Unenforceability and Its Distinction from Similar Concepts]. Molate'at-e Hoquq-e Khososi [Private Law Studies], Vol. 50, No. 1 [in Persian].
  34. Roudijani, Mohammad Mojtaba (1397 SH/2018). Qānūn-e Omūr-e Ḥasbī dar Naẓm-e Ḥoqūqī-ye Konūnī [Non-Contentious Matters Law in Current Legal Order] (1st ed.). Tehran: Ava [in Persian].
  35. Saatchi, Ali (1392 SH/2013). Naẓarīyeh-ye ʿUmūmī-ye Vażʿīyat-e Morāʿā dar Aʿmāl-e Ḥoqūqī [General Theory of Pending Status in Juridical Acts] (Master's thesis). Tehran: Shahid Beheshti University [in Persian].
  36. Shahidi, Mehdi (1377 SH/1998). Taškīl-e Qarārdādhā va Taʿahhodāt [Formation of Contracts and Obligations] (1st ed.). Tehran: Hoquqdan [in Persian].
  37. Shahidi, Mehdi (1384 SH/2005). Erṯ [Inheritance] (2nd ed.). Tehran: Majd [in Persian].
  38. Shams, Abdollah (1380 SH/2001). Āyīn-e Dādrasī-ye Madanī [Civil Procedure] (Vol. 1, 1st ed.). Tehran: Mizan [in Persian].
  39. Tabatabai Yazdi, Sayyid Mohammad Kazim (1417 AH/1996). al-ʿUrwat al-vuṯqā (Vol. 6, 1st ed.). Qom: Islamic Publications Office [in Arabic].
  40. Tustari, Asadollah (n.d.). Muqābis al-anwār va nafāʾis al-asrār (1st ed.). Qom: Aal al-Bayt Institute [in Arabic].

  • Received 12 October 2025
  • Accepted 29 November 2025