Journal of Islamic Law Research

Journal of Islamic Law Research

Updating Damages Incurred by the Buyer of a Non-Owned Object of Sale from the Time of Final Judgment to Enforcement in Iranian Law

Type : Research Article

Authors
1 PhD Student in Private Law, Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies, Meybod University, Meybod, Iran.
2 Associate Professor, Department of Law, Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies, Meybod University, Meybod, Iran.
Abstract
 ‌Context & Objective: In Iranian legal practice, when a sale is invalidated due to the object of sale not belonging to the seller, the buyer is legally entitled to recover the paid price and receive compensation for the diminished value of the currency, based on item-specific inflation. This right has been affirmed by Uniform Judicial Decisions Nos. 733 and 811 of the General Assembly of the Supreme Court of Iran, which are binding across all courts. Nonetheless, a recurring legal issue arises when there is a significant delay between the issuance of a final judgment and the enforcement of the ruling. Such delays can result in further economic loss for the buyer, particularly in unauthorized transactions [fuḍūlī]. The legal principle of res judicata restricts revisiting judicial findings post-judgment, yet practical consequences of delayed enforcement remain unresolved. This study aims to address the research question: How can Iranian law ensure full compensation to the buyer when a final judgment is delayed in its enforcement?
 ‌Method & Approach: This research employs a doctrinal legal methodology, relying on comprehensive analysis of statutory law, authoritative judicial precedents, and scholarly interpretations within the Iranian legal system. The study particularly examines the interpretive function of item-specific versus general inflation indices in judicial remedies and investigates how these concepts can be applied in sequential stages—before and after judgment issuance—to close the compensation gap in delayed enforcement scenarios.
 ‌Findings: The study finds that while item-specific inflation is the appropriate measure for calculating loss in purchasing power up to the date of final judgment, it becomes inadequate once a ruling has been issued. For the period following the judgment until its enforcement, using the general inflation index released by the Central Bank of Iran emerges as a legally and practically viable method to ensure fair compensation. This adjustment not only upholds the economic interests of the buyer but also provides clarity and consistency for enforcement authorities, mitigating the ambiguity often associated with post-judgment compensation enforcement.
 ‌Conclusion: To maintain the effectiveness and finality of judicial rulings while safeguarding the buyer’s financial interests, Iranian courts should adopt a dual-inflation approach: apply item-specific inflation for pre-judgment losses and general inflation for the post-judgment enforcement delay. This model balances doctrinal consistency with practical fairness, enhancing both the legitimacy and enforceability of court decisions in cases involving unauthorized sales.
Keywords
Subjects

  1. Abedian, Mir Hossein, Asadzadeh, Mojtaba & Firouzmand, Ali (1392 SH/2013). Dar Takāpū-ye ʿAdālat [In Pursuit of Justice]. Tehran: Mizan [in Persian].
  2. Al-sharif, Mohammad Mahdi (1401 SH/2022). Manṭiq-e Ḥuqūq [Logic of Law]. Tehran: Enteshar Co. [in Persian].
  3. Ansari, Mehdi (1393 SH/2014). Taḥlīl-e Iqtiṣādī-ye Ḥuqūq-e Qarārdādhā [Economic Analysis of Contract Law]. Tehran: Javadaneh [in Persian].
  4. Babaei, Iraj (1386 SH/2007). Mabānī-ye Naẓarī-ye Rūykard-e Taḥlīl-e Iqtiṣādī-ye Ḥuqūq [Theoretical Foundations of Economic Analysis of Law Approach]. Pazhuhesh-e Hoquq va Siasat [Law and Politics Research], 9(23), pp. 13-60 [in Persian].
  5. Bagheri, Yousef & Sedaghati, Saham (1393 SH/2014). Shākhiṣahhā-ye Raʾy-e Qavī va Mutaqan [Characteristics of a Strong and Solid Judgment]. Majalleh Ghezavat [Ghezavat Magazine], 14(79), pp. 149-180 [in Persian].
  6. Bahmani, Mohammad (1386 SH/2007). Murūrī bar Shīvahhā-ye Khāṣṣ-e Arzyābī-ye Khasārat-e Qarārdādī bā Takyah bar Mavādd-e 75 va 76-e Kunvānsīyūn-e Bayʿ-e Bayn al-Milalī-ye Kālā va Ḥuqūq-e Īrān [A Review of Specific Methods for Assessing Contractual Damages Relying on Articles 75 and 76 of the CISG and Iranian Law]. Tahqiqat-e Hoquq-e Tatbiqi-ye Iran va Bayn al-Melal [Iran and International Comparative Law Research], 1(1), pp. 39-82 [in Persian].
  7. Ghamami, Mohammad Mehdi (1398 SH/2019). Taḥavvul-e Niẓām-e Qażāyī bā Taʾkīd bar Kārāmadī-ye Farāyand-e Ṣudūr-e Ārāy-e Qażāyī [Evolution of the Judicial System with Emphasis on the Efficiency of the Judgment Issuing Process]. Faslnameh Didgah-haye Hoquq-e Qazaei [Judicial Law Views Quarterly], 24(85), pp. 29-54 [in Persian].
  8. Golbaghi Masouleh, Ali Jabbar (1399 SH/2020). Darāmadī bar ʿUrf [An Introduction to Custom]. Qom: Boustan-e Ketab Institute [in Persian].
  9. Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar (1388 SH/2009). Vasīṭ dar Tirmīnūlūzhī-ye Ḥuqūq [Vasit in Terminology of Law]. Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh [in Persian].
  10. Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar (1396 SH/2017). Tirmīnūlūzhī-ye Ḥuqūq [Terminology of Law]. Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh [in Persian].
  11. Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar (1401 SH/2022). Falsafah-ye ʿUmūmī-ye Ḥuqūq [General Philosophy of Law]. Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh [in Persian].
  12. Jafari, Nasrallah & Naseri, Parisa (1403 SH/2024). Arziš-e Rūz-e Mabīʿ dar Tarāzū-ye Sanjish-e Gharāmāt-e Kharīdār va Qāʿidahnāmand-sāzī-ye Raʾy-e Vaḥdat-e Ravīyah-ye Shumārah-ye 811 [The Day-Value of the Object of Sale in the Balance of Buyer's Damages Assessment and Systematizing Precedent Judgment No. 811]. Motaleat-e Hoquqi [Legal Studies], 16(3), pp. 193-218. doi: 10.22099/jls.2023.47386.4953 [in Persian].
  13. Jafaritabar, Hasan (1401 SH/2022). Manṭiq-e Ḥayrānī dar Bāb-e Istidlāl-e Ḥuqūqī [The Logic of Perplexity regarding Legal Reasoning]. Tehran: Nashr-e Naw [in Persian].
  14. Karimi, Abbas & Jawaherkalam, Mohammad Hadi (1399 SH/2020). Taḥlīl-e Raʾy-e Vaḥdat-e Ravīyah-ye Shumārah-ye 733-e Hayʾat-e ʿUmūmī-ye Dīvān-e ʿĀlī-ye Kishvar bā Taʾkīd bar Māhiyat-e Pūl va Tamāyuz-e Kลดāhish-e Arziš-e Pūl, Khasārat-e Taʾkhīr-e Taʾdiyah va Khasārat-e Nāshī az Afzāyish-e Qaymathā [Analysis of Precedent Judgment No. 733 of the General Board of the Supreme Court with Emphasis on the Nature of Money and the Distinction Between Money Depreciation, Delay Damages, and Price Increase Damages]. Doufaslnameh Daneshnameh Hoquq-e Eqtesadi [Economic Law Encyclopedia Biannual], 27(17), pp. 1-24. doi: 10.22067/lowecon.2021.47236.0 [in Persian].
  15. Katouzian, Nasser (1392 SH/2013). Iʿtibār-e Amr-e Qażāvat-Shudah dar Daʿvī-ye Madanī [Res Judicata in Civil Lawsuits]. Tehran: Mizan [in Persian].
  16. Katouzian, Nasser (1399 SH/2020). Masʾūlīyat-e Madanī (Vol. 1) [Civil Liability]. Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh [in Persian].
  17. Katouzian, Nasser (1400 SH/2021). Falsafah-ye Ḥuqūq (Vol. 2) [Philosophy of Law]. Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh [in Persian].
  18. Katouzian, Nasser (1401 SH/2022). Falsafah-ye Ḥuqūq (Vols. 1 & 3) [Philosophy of Law]. Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh [in Persian].
  19. Khodabakhshi, Abdollah (1389 SH/2010). al-Ghāṣib Yuʾkhaẕu bi-Ashadd al-Aḥvāl [The Usurper is Held to the Severest Conditions]. Feqh-e Ahl-e Bayt [Ahl al-Bayt Jurisprudence], 16(61), pp. 107-136 [in Persian].
  20. Khodabakhshi, Abdollah (1401 SH/2022). Falsafah-ye Ḥuqūq (Vol. 2) [Philosophy of Law]. Tehran: Enteshar Co. [in Persian].
  21. Mirshekari, Abbas & Hosseini, Fatemeh Sadat (1399 SH/2020). Imkānsanjī-ye Muṭālabah-ye Qaymat-e Afzāyish-Yāftah-ye Mabīʿ az Bāyiʿ-e Fużūlī bā Tavajjuh bih Ravīyah-ye Qażāyī [Feasibility of Claiming the Increased Price of the Object of Sale from the Unauthorized Seller Considering Judicial Practice]. Doufaslnameh Hoquq-e Qarardad-ha va Fannari-haye Navin [Contracts Law and New Technologies Biannual], 1(1), pp. 221-255. doi: 10.22133/clj.2020.236829.1002 [in Persian].
  22. Mirzanazhad Jouybari, Akbar & Khoshnoudi, Reza (1400 SH/2021). Khasārat-e Taʾkhīr-e Taʾdiyah dar Ravīyah-ye Qażāyī bā Muṭālaʿah-ye Taṭbīqī-ye Ḥuqūq-e Farānsah [Delay Damages in Judicial Practice with a Comparative Study of French Law]. Tehran: Judiciary Research Institute [in Persian].
  23. Mohaghegh Damad, Seyyed Mostafa (1394 SH/2015). Qavāʿid-e Feqh [Rules of Jurisprudence]. Tehran: Islamic Sciences Publishing Center [in Persian].
  24. Mohseni, Hasan & Mirshekari, Abbas (1394 SH/2015). Muṭālabah-ye Zīyān-e Dīrkard-e Pardākht-e Dayn-e Nāshī az Żimān-e Qahrī [Claiming Damages for Delayed Payment of Debt Arising from Tortious Liability]. Faslnameh Motaleat-e Hoquq-e Khosousi [Private Law Studies Quarterly], 46(1), pp. 139-151. doi: 10.22059/jlq.2016.57528 [in Persian].
  25. Mousavi, Seyyed Abbas (1402 SH/2023). Mahārathā-ye Dādrasī [Adjudication Skills]. Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh [in Persian].
  26. Nahreini, Fereydoun (1401 SH/2022). Īstāyī-ye Ijrā-ye Ḥukm-e Dādgāh [Stagnation of Court Judgment Execution]. Tehran: Ganj-e Danesh [in Persian].
  27. Pourostad, Majid & Imanian, A'zam (1390 SH/2011). Mālikīyat-e Khvāhān bar Daʿvī-ye Madanī [Plaintiff's Ownership of Civil Lawsuit]. Nashriyeh Tahqiqat-e Hoquq-e Bayn al-Melali [International Legal Research Journal], 14(14), pp. 42-74 [in Persian].
  28. Riyahi, Ali Akbar (1400 SH/2021). Fan-ne Vikālat [The Art of Advocacy] (M. H. Zahedin Labbaf, Trans.). Tehran: Shahr-e Danesh [in Persian].
  29. Sadeghian, Mahdieh, Ziaoleslami, Ali & Sadeghirad, Mehdi (1403 SH/2024). Taḥlīl-e Intiqādī-ye Mabānī-ye Raʾy-e Vaḥdat-e Ravīyah-ye 811-e Hayʾat-e ʿUmūmī-ye Dīvān-e ʿĀlī-ye Kishvar [Critical Analysis of the Foundations of Precedent Judgment No. 811 of the General Board of the Supreme Court]. Faslnameh Tahqiqat-e Hoquqi [Legal Research Quarterly], 27(3), pp. 256-274. doi: 10.48308/jlr.2024.229734.2379 [in Persian].
  30. Shams, Abdollah (1401 SH/2022, a). Ijrā-ye Aḥkām-e Madanī (Vols. 1 & 2) [Execution of Civil Judgments]. Tehran: Darak [in Persian].
  31. Shams, Abdollah (1401 SH/2022, b). Āyīn-e Dādrasī-ye Madanī (Vols. 1 & 2) [Civil Procedure Code]. Tehran: Darak [in Persian].

  • Received 11 February 2025
  • Accepted 15 April 2025