Unacknowledged Islamic Legal Capacities in International Documentation: A Case Study of "Organisation of Islamic Cooperation's Strategy on the Elderly"

Document Type : Research Article

Author

Assistant Professor, Department of International Law, Faculty of Law, University of Qom, Qom, Iran.

Abstract

‌ ∴ Introduction ∴ ‌
The Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) has recognized the impending demographic shift within its 57 member states, particularly concerning the aging population. Despite numerous international initiatives addressing demographic changes, the legal capacities within Islamic teachings regarding the rights of the elderly remain underexplored in international documentation. This extended abstract explores the unacknowledged Islamic legal capacities within the OIC's strategy on the elderly, shedding light on the neglected aspects of Islamic jurisprudence in addressing aging populations.
‌ ∴ Research Question ∴ ‌
This study seeks to investigate whether the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, as a religious entity, has effectively incorporated Islamic legal values into its strategy on the elderly. It aims to discern the extent to which Islamic legal principles are reflected in the documentation, highlighting any discrepancies between religious teachings and international policy frameworks.
‌ ∴ Research Hypothesis ∴ ‌
It is hypothesized that while the OIC's strategy on the elderly may demonstrate recognition of the importance of addressing aging populations, there may be a gap in the integration of Islamic legal principles into the documentation. The hypothesis suggests that the OIC's strategy may not fully capitalize on the rich heritage of Islamic jurisprudence concerning the rights and protections afforded to the elderly.
‌ ∴ Methodology & Framework, if Applicable ∴ ‌
Utilizing an analytical and descriptive approach, this study examines the OIC's strategy on the elderly, focusing on the foundational instrument approved in 2020. The methodology involves a comprehensive review and analysis of the text, with particular attention to the incorporation of Islamic legal principles. The framework for analysis encompasses several key aspects: the position of religious elements in documentation, the utilization of non-religious discourse, the convergence of member states' legislation on elderly rights, the role of women and family, and the introduction of new terminologies. These components provide a structured framework for evaluating the extent to which Islamic legal capacities are acknowledged and integrated within the OIC's strategy on the elderly.
     In the subsequent sections of this extended abstract, the study will delve deeper into each aspect of the framework, offering critical insights into the documentation and its alignment with Islamic legal principles. The analysis aims to contribute to a better understanding of the intersection between religious values and international policy initiatives concerning aging populations within Islamic societies.
‌ ∴ Results & Discussion ∴ ‌
The analysis of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation's strategy on the elderly reveals several noteworthy findings and prompts critical discussion regarding the integration of Islamic legal principles, the focus on financial matters, and the representation of women and family within the instrument.
     The results indicate that while the strategy demonstrates timely recognition of population aging in Islamic societies, it falls short in substantively incorporating Islamic legal values. The instrument primarily emphasizes financial aspects and resource allocation, neglecting to establish qualitative criteria based on Sharia for addressing elderly rights. This raises questions about the extent to which the instrument reflects the unique legal heritage of Islamic societies and distinguishes itself from other international frameworks.
     Furthermore, the discussion highlights the instrument’s approach to representing women and family within the context of elderly issues. While there is some attempt to deviate from state-centric obligations and acknowledge the role of women and family, the instrument’s treatment remains limited. This raises broader questions about the intersectionality of gender, family dynamics, and elderly rights within Islamic legal frameworks and international policy discourse.
     Additionally, the analysis identifies shortcomings in the instrument’s utilization of innovative terminologies and legal convergence. The absence of an approach rooted in the realities of Islamic societies regarding labor rights and social security underscores the need for a more nuanced understanding of Islamic jurisprudence in addressing aging populations.
‌ ∴ Conclusion ∴ ‌
In conclusion, the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation's strategy on the elderly represents a significant step towards addressing the challenges posed by population aging in Islamic societies. However, the instrument falls short of fully capitalizing on Islamic legal capacities, particularly in establishing qualitative criteria based on Sharia for elderly rights. The absence of substantive values and the limited representation of women and family highlight areas for improvement in future iterations of the strategy.
     The conclusion emphasizes the importance of incorporating national and religious culture into legal frameworks related to the elderly, as seen in the case of Iran. By aligning laws and instruments with Islamic principles, there is an opportunity to not only address domestic needs but also serve as a legislative model for other Islamic countries. Furthermore, the inclusion of innovative terminologies and a forward-looking understanding of Sharia can influence global discourse on elderly rights, extending beyond Islamic states.
     In essence, the critique and evaluation of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation's strategy on the elderly underscore the ongoing dialogue between national and international legal levels and the imperative of integrating Islamic legal principles into contemporary policy frameworks.

Keywords

Main Subjects


  1. The Holy Quran.
  2. Nahj al-Balāgha, Amīr al-Mu'minīn ‘Imam Alī (PBUH).
  3. Annamma, Subini Ancy, Darrell D. Jackson, & Deb Morrison (2017). "Conceptualizing color-evasiveness: Using dis/ability critical race theory to expand a color-blind racial ideology in education and society." Race ethnicity and education 20, no. 2, pp. 147-162.
  4. Arasṭā, Moḥammad Javād (1398 SH). Nizām Ḥuqūq-e Bashar-e Eslāmī (Barresī Mabānī Fiqhī E’lāmīye Eslāmī Ḥuqūq Bashar) (Volume 2) [Islamic Human Rights System (Study of Jurisprudential Foundations of the Islamic Declaration of Human Rights)]. Qom: Markaz-e Pazhūheshī Mabnā [in Persian].
  5. Augenstein, Daniel & Dawson, Mark (2012). What Law for What polity: integration through law in the EU Revisited" in Augenstein, Daniel, ed. 'Integration through law'revisited: the making of the European polity. Routledge.
  6. Bāqerī-Fard, Moḥammad Ḥossein (1396 SH). Qānūn-gozārī Farhangī [Cultural Legislation]. Markaz Taḥqīqāt Eslāmī Majles va Enteshārāt Khorsandī [in Persian].
  7. Barāzesh, ‘Alīrezā (1396 SH). Tafsīr Ahl al-Bayt [Interpretation of the People of the House]. Translated by Sayyed Rasoul Behesthi-Nejad, Habil Javani, and Mostafa Khalash. 2nd ed., Vol. 10, Tehran: Amīrkabīr [in Persian].
  8. Baumgart-Ochse, Claudia. (2015). Which gets protection-belief or believer? The organisation of Islamic cooperation and the campaign against the'Defamation of Religions' ,Vol. 136, p. 31. DEU.
  9. Bradford, A., & Posner, E. A. (2011). Universal Exceptionalism in International Law. Harvard International Law Journal , 52 (1), pp. 1-54
  10. Burd, M., & Davies, J. (2013). Age discrimination: A practical guide to the law, Lewis Silkin LLP. Lewis Silkin LLP, 2013.
  11. Cahill, Suzanne (2020). "WHO's global action plan on the public health response to dementia: some challenges and opportunities." Aging & Mental Health, 24, no. 2, pp. 197-199.
  12. Ceaser, J. W (2012). “The Origins and Character of American Exceptionalism”. American Political Thought, 1, 2012, pp. 1-26
  13. Coals, T., Heasman, K., Heasman, S., Lawrence, L., Price, A., Renton, D., et al (2006). Challenging Age Discrimination: A NATFHE policy document. London: NATFHE.
  14. Darāhkī, Aḥmad, and Nowbakhṭ, Rezā (1399 SH). Barrasī Vaż‘īyat-e Eqteṣādī va Ejtemā‘ī Zanān Sālmand-e Īrānī Bar Asās Āmārhā-ye Rasmi va Elzāmāt-e Sīāsatī Mobtenī Bar Pīshbīnī-hā-ye Āyandeh-Negarāneh Jom‘īyatī [Study on the Socio-Economic Status of Elderly Iranian Women Based on Official Statistics and Policy Requirements Based on Demographic Forecasts]. Pāyesh (Pajūheshkadeh Jahād Dāneshgāhī), Vol. 19, No. 6, pp. 621-633. doi:10.29252/payesh.19.6.621 [in Persian].
  15. Douglas-Scott, Sionaidh (2011). “The European Union and Human Rights after the Treaty of Lisbon”, Human Rights Law Review , 11 (4), pp. 645-682.
  16. Dowkhā’ī, Erfāneh (1400 SH). Barrasī Ejmālī Algoūye Keshvarhā-ye Pīshgām dar Ḥawzeh Bīmeh Sālmandī [A Brief Review of the Model of Leading Countries in the Field of Elderly Insurance]. 1st ed., Tehran: Edāre Kol-e Rovābat ‘Ommī va Omūr Bayn al-Melalī Sāzmān Bīmeh Salāmat Īrān [in Persian].
  17. Edmunds, Aneira J (2021). "Precarious bodies: The securitization of the “veiled” woman in European human rights." The British Journal of Sociology, 72, no. 2, pp. 315-327.
  18. Fakhrzādeh, Hossein and Soltānī Mahajar, Hourieh (1396 SH). Jāygāh Sālmandān va Marāqebat az Salāmat-e Ānhā dar Eslām [The Position of the Elderly and Care for Their Health in Islam]. Faslnāmeh Ṭibb va Tazkīyeh, 26 (2), pp. 97-104 [in Persian].
  19. Ghosheh, Naj (2008). Age Discrimination and Older Workers: Theory and Legislation in Comparative Context, International Labour Office – Geneva, Conditions of Work and Employment Programme (Conditions of Work and Employment Series No. 20, 61 Pages.
  20. Gunn, T. Jeremy, & Alvaro Lagresa (2016). "The Organisation of Islamic Cooperation: Universal Human Rights, Islamic Values, or Raisons d'Etat." Hum. Rts. & Int'l Legal Discourse 10 , p. 248.
  21. Ḥabīb Nezhād, Sayyed Ahmad, and Tasḵīrī, Moḥammad Ṣāleḥ (1395 SH). Taqnīn Mushtarak Keshvarhā-ye Eslāmī dar Ḥawzeh Ḥuqūq-e Bashar-Dūstāneh [Joint Legislation of Islamic Countries in the Field of Humanitarian Law]. Pajūhesh Tatbīqī Ḥuqūq-e Eslām va Gharb, 3 (4). doi:10.22091/csiw.2018.1664.1141 [in Persian].
  22. Ḥekmat-Niā, Hasan, Mir Najaf Mousavi, Kamran Jafarpour Ghalehteimouri, Ali Shamsoddini, Ali Bagheri Kashkouli & Alireza Jamshidi (2022). "Population Aging Tendencies in Islamic Countries Between 1950-2020: A Geographical Assessment." Journal of Population and Social Studies [JPSS] 30, pp. 36-53.
  23. Ḥekmat-Niā, Maḥmūd (1394 SH). Cheraī va Chīgūnagī Taqnīn Akhlāq [The Why and How of Ethics Legislation]. Faslnāmeh Dīn va Qānūn, Issue 9, pp. 67-92 [in Persian].
  24. Huntoon, Lawrence R (2013). "The Affordable Care Act: a planned transition to socialized medicine." Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons 18, no. 4, pp. 98-100.
  25. Ḥurr ‘Āmilī, Moḥammad bin Ḥasan (1370 AH). Wasā'il al-Shī‘a (Volume 25). Qom: Mo’asseseh Āl al-Bayt ‘alayhem al-Salām Lāḥyā’ al-Turāth [in Arabic].
  26. Ḥurr ‘Āmilī, Moḥammad bin Ḥasan (1372 AH). Wasā'il al-Shī‘a (Volume 15). Qom: Mo’asseseh Āl al-Bayt ‘alayhem al-Salām Lāḥyā’ al-Turāth [in Arabic].
  27. Ḥurr ‘Āmilī, Moḥammad bin Ḥasan (1373 AH). Wasā'il al-Shī‘a (Volume 12). Qom: Mo’asseseh Āl al-Bayt ‘alayhem al-Salām Lāḥyā’ al-Turāth [in Arabic].
  28. Ignatieff, M (2005). American Exceptionalism and Human Rights. In American Exceptionalism and Human Rights (pp. 1-26). Princeton University Press.
  29. Īsāzādeh, ‘Īsā (1399 SH). Mahārat-hā-ye Ertebātī bā Sālmandān Bar Asās Āmūzeh-hā-ye Qur'ān va Ahl-e Bayt ‘alayhem al-salām [Communication Skills with the Elderly Based on the Teachings of the Quran and Ahl al-Bayt]. Nashr-e Pazhūheshgāh ‘Olūm va Farhang-e Eslāmī [in Persian].
  30. Islam, Md Rabiul (2016). Ageism and Age Discrimination in Old Age: An Overview, Philosophy and Progress , 55 (2), pp. 91-108.
  31. Jaspal, Rusi & Glynis M. Breakwell (2022). "Socio-economic inequalities in social network, loneliness and mental health during the COVID-19 pandemic", International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 68, no. 1, pp. 155-165.
  32. Karlifeh, Samieh (2022). Al-Juhūd al-Dawliyyah liḥimāyat ḥuqūq al-Musinnīn min khilāl dawr al-Munazzamāt al-Dawliyyah [International Efforts to Protect the Rights of the Elderly through the Role of International Organizations]. The Seventh International Scientific Conference on the Rights of the Elderly between Reality and Hope organized by the Faculty of Law, University of Tanta, Arab Republic of Egypt [in Arabic].
  33. Kāẓemī Najafābādī, Mostafā and Hosseinī, Seyed Rezā (Autumn and Winter 1400 SH). Taḥlīl Sākhtār Fiqhī Hazinehā va Darāmadhā-ye Takaful Ejtemā'ī [Analysis of the Jurisprudential Structure of Expenses and Revenues of Social Takaful]. Ma‘refat Eqtesād Eslāmī, Year 13, Issue 1, consecutive 25, pp. 7-26 [in Persian].
  34. Khomeinī, Sayyid Rūḥollah (1379 SH). Taḥrīr al-Wasīla (Volume 1). Mo’asseseh Tanzīm va Nashr Āthār Imām Khomeinī (ra) [in Arabic].
  35. Kirchin, S. (2007). Moral Particularism: An Introduction. Journal of Moral Philosophy , 4 (1),pp. 8-15.
  36. Koh, Harold Hongju (2003). “On American Exceptionalism”, Stanford Law Review (Yale Law School Legal Scholarship Repository) , 55, pp. 1479-1527.
  37. Kulwicki, Anahid Dervartanian (2021). "People of Arab heritage." in Textbook for Transcultural Health Care: A Population Approach: Cultural Competence Concepts in Nursing Care, pp. 251-276.
  38. Lebret, Audrey (2020). "COVID-19 pandemic and derogation to human rights", Journal of Law and the Biosciences 7, no. 1: lsaa015.
  39. Li, Fengyue & Otani, Junko (2018). "Financing elderly people's long‐term care needs: Evidence from C hina." The International journal of health planning and management 33, no. 2, pp. 479-488.
  40. Madrid Plan of Action on Ageing (2002). Second United Nations World Assembly on Ageing.
  41. McCann, Laurie (2011). "Age discrimination in employment legislation in the United States experience." Washington DC: AARP Foundation Litigation.
  42. Menkel-Meadow, Carrie (2011). “Why and How to Study Transnational Law”, UC Irvine Law Review, vol. 1(1), pp. 97-129.
  43. Mīrmohammadī, Seyed Mostafā (1396 SH). Barnāmehā-ye ‘Amal-e Dah-Sāleh Sāzmān-e Hamkārī Eslāmī; Solḥ va Amnīyat Beyn al-Melalī [Ten-Year Action Plans of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation; International Peace and Security]. Pajūhesh Tatbīqī Ḥuqūq-e Eslām va Gharb, 4 (1), pp. 173-202. doi:10.22091/csiw.2018.1594.1134 [in Persian].
  44. Mo'men, Raqiye al-Sādāt (1400 SH). Bāzkhānī Hovīyat Zan dar Sonnat-e ‘Alavī [Re-reading the Identity of Women in Alavi Tradition]. 1st ed., Dāneshgāh Emām Ṣādeq (AS) [in Persian].
  45. Mousavī Asl, Sayyed Ḥasan and Ṭabāṭabā'ī, Sayyed Aḥmad (1399 SH). Roykard Sāzmān-e Hamkārī Eslāmī; az Roygardānī tā Tavajjoh be Ḥuqūq-e Bashar [The Approach of the Islamic Cooperation Organization; From Neglect to Attention to Human Rights]. Motāle‘āt Ḥuqūq-e Tatbīqī Mo‘āṣer, 11 (21). doi:10.22034/law.2021.39087.2567 [in Persian].
  46. Mousavī Asl, Sayyed Ḥasan and Zamānī, Sayyed Qāsem (1401 SH). Rāstī-Āzmā'ī Gerāyesh Sāzmān-e Hamkārī Eslāmī be Roykardī Darūn-Gerā dar Zemīneh Ḥuqūq-e Bashar [Verifying the Islamic Cooperation Organization's Inward Approach in the Field of Human Rights]. Pajūhesh Tatbīqī Ḥuqūq-e Eslām va Gharb, 9 (2), pp. 299-326. doi:10.22091/CSIW.2021.6312.1965 [in Persian].
  47. Moẓaffarī, Moḥammad Ḥossein (1389 SH). Manshūr Ḥuqūq-e Bashar-e Eslāmī (Chālesh-hā va Rāhkarhā) [Islamic Human Rights Charter (Challenges and Solutions)]. Enteshārāt Dāneshgāh Emām Ṣādeq (AS) [in Persian].
  48. Mozaffari, M. H. (2020). OIC Declaration on Human Rights: Changing the name or a paradigm change. The Raoul Wallenberg Institute of Human Rights and Humanitarian Law.
  49. Nabavī, Seyed Ḥamīd, Asadī Lārī, Mohsen, Mousavī, Mīr Ṭāher, Rāshidī, Vahīd, and Fedā'ī Vatan, Rezā (1401 SH). Taḥlīl Chand-Satḥī Shabakeh Ejtemā'ī Sālmandān Bar Asās Dādeh-hā-ye Fāz-e Dovvom Motāle'eh ‘Adālat dar Salāmat-e Shahrī [Multilevel Analysis of the Social Network of the Elderly Based on the Data of the Second Phase of the Urban Health Equity Study]. Sālmand (Iranian Journal of Ageing), 17 (1), pp. 28-43. doi:10.32598/sija.2021.1681.2 [in Persian].
  50. Najafābādī Qorbānpūr, ‘Alīrezā and Goodarzī, Mahnāz (Winter 1395 SH). Boḥrān-e Eqteṣādī va Mālī-ye Etteḥādīye Orūpā va Ham-gerāyī Sīāsī va Amnīyatī Orūpā'ī [The Economic and Financial Crisis of the European Union and the European Political and Security Convergence]. Faslnāmeh Motāle‘āt Ravābet Beyn al-Melal, Year 9, Issue 36, pp. 104-138 [in Persian].
  51. Numhauser-Henning, Ann (2013). "The EU ban on age-discrimination and older workers: Potentials and pitfalls." International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations, 29, no. 4.
  52. Pampel, Fred C (2008). Rights Of The Elderly, Infobase Publishing.
  53. Rosas, Allan (2001). Is the EU a Human Rights Organisation?, Centre For The Law Of EU External Relations (CLEER Working Papers 2011/1).
  54. Sādāt Akhavī, Sayyed ‘Alī (1385 SH). Qā‘edeh Qānūn Maṭlūb-Tar Be ‘Onvān Zābeṭeh Ḥall Ta‘āroz Mīān Mo‘āhedāt Ḥuqūq Basharī [The Most Desired Law Rule as a Criterion for Resolving Conflicts Between Human Rights Treaties]. Majalleh Dāneshkadeh Ḥuqūq va ‘Ulūm Sīāsī, No. 72, pp. 201-219 [in Persian].
  55. Ṣadūq (Ibn Bābūyah), Moḥammad bin ‘Alī (1383 AH). ‘Ilal al-Sharā'i‘ (Volume 2). Maktabat al-Ḥeydarīya [in Arabic].
  56. Schulz, Richard & Jill Eden (2016). eds, Families caring for an aging America, Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
  57. Shaffer, Gregory & Mark A. Pollack (2012). Hard and soft law: what have we learned?, in International Law and International Relations: Insights from Interdisciplinary Scholarship, Jeffrey L. Dunoff and Mark A. Pollack (eds.),(New York: Cambridge University Press, 2012), Minnesota Legal Studies Research Paper 12-17.
  58. Ṭabāṭabā'ī, Moḥammad Ḥossein (1383 SH). Tarjomeh Tafsīr al-Mīzān [Translation of Tafsir al-Mizan]. Translated by Sayyed Mohammad Baqer Mousavi Hamedani. Vol. 15, Qom: Daftar-e Enteshārāt-e Eslāmī affiliated with Jāme'eh Modarresīn Hawzeh ‘Elmiyyeh Qom [in Arabic].
  59. Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action (1993). the World Conference on Human Rights in Vienna.
  60. Wamara, Charles Kiiza, Maria Bennich & Thomas Strandberg (2021). "Missing voices: older people’s perspectives on being abused in Uganda." Journal of Elder Abuse & Neglect 33, no. 4, pp. 288-310.
  61. Wessel, Ramses A (2010). Towards World Legislation? The Exercise of Public Authority by International Institutions, conference World Legislation: Perspectives from International Law, Legal Theory and Political Philosophy, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam.
  62. Wessel, Ramses A (2011). “Informal International Law-Making as a New Form of World Legislation”, International Organizations Law Review, vol. 8, pp. 253–265.
  63. Yāvarī, Kāẓem, Bāsakhā, Mehdī, Ṣādeqī, Hossein, and Nāserī, ‘Alīrezā (1394 SH). Negāhī bar Āsār Eqteṣādī Pādīdeh-ye Sālmandī [A Look at the Economic Effects of the Aging Phenomenon]. Faslnāmeh Sālmand, 10 (1), pp. 92-105 [in Persian].