The Nordic Approach, Emerging Corporate Governance Regime; A Comparative Study of Scandinavian Countries and Iranian Law

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies, Meybod University, Meybod, Iran.

2 LLM Student in Private Law, Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies, Meybod University, Meybod, Iran.

Abstract

Distinct encounters with the concept of "Corporate Governance Regime" have given rise to diverse perspectives. Prior studies in Iran guided us towards the prevalent approaches, namely "Anglo-American" and "Continental European," followed by "East Asian." However, in the last two decades in Scandinavian countries, the "Nordic Approach" (semi-dualistic) has emerged from within the "Continental European" framework. Its primary tenets include reliance on the "Stakeholder Theory," "Controlling Shareholder," and "Employee Participation in the Board of Directors," with distinctive features such as "Concentrated Ownership," "Semi-Dual Board," "Bank-Centric Financial Provision," and "High Financial Transparency" serving as its key indicators. Consequently, this research seeks to explore the distinctions and commonalities of the "Corporate Governance Regime" in the Nordic approach and Iranian law through a comparative study and an analytical-descriptive methodology.
     Despite noteworthy theoretical and practical efforts in Iranian law to elucidate and actualize the "Corporate Governance Regime" by issuing directives and mandatory regulations for joint-stock companies active in the stock exchange market by the Securities and Exchange Organization's board of directors, the absence of coherent, unitary regulations in this regard has posed challenges for joint-stock companies and their supervision. The elucidation of the "Nordic Approach" in this research, with the aforementioned features, suggests, for the first time in Iranian law, the proposal of regulations aligned with "The Future Law of Commercial Companies" that allocate independent sections to the corporate governance regime. This includes recommendations such as "structural alterations to the board of directors and the establishment of a supervisory body, incorporating shareholders and employees to enhance employee rights," "increasing incentives for the active presence of joint-stock companies in the stock market," aiming to secure more financial resources through the market itself rather than relying solely on entities such as banks, and "incorporating transparency requirements into the regulations of the stock exchange's independent section from the law."

Keywords

Main Subjects


  1. Draft Law amending a portion of the Iranian Commercial Code, approved in 1347 SH.
  2. Securities Market Law of the Islamic Republic of Iran, approved in 1384 SH.
  3. Abedini, Hossein (1397 SH). Public Joint Stock Company Governance System; Providing a Suitable Model for the Iranian Legal System with a Comparative Study on American Companies (Doctoral Thesis, Kharazmi University).
  4. Abedini, Hossein (1400 SH). Comparative Study of Key Indicators of Corporate Governance in the East Asia Approach and Iranian Law. Quarterly Journal of Private Law Studies, Volume 51, Number 3, 469-486.
  5. Calkoen, Willem Jacob Lodewijk. (2011). The One-Tier Board In The Changing and Converging World of Corporate Governance.
  6. Danish Corporate Governance Committee, Finnish Securities Market Association, Icelandic Committee on Corporate Governance, Norwegian Corporate Governance Board, & Swedish Corporate Governance Board. (2009). Corporate Governance In The Nordic Countries.
  7. Danish Recommendations on Corporate Governance, (2020).
  8. Davies, Paul L, & Hopt, Klaus J. (2013). Corporate Boards In Europe-Accountability and Convergence. The American Journal of Comparative Law, 61(2), 301–376.
  9. Eelderink, GJ. (2014). Effect of ownership structure on firm performance. University of Twente.
  10. Eisaie Tafreshi, Mohammad, and Yahyapour, Jamshid (1392 SH). Interest Theory with a Focus on the Regulations of Iranian Joint Stock Companies. Securities and Exchange Quarterly, Number 23, 139-167.
  11. Friedman, Andrew L, & Miles, Samantha. (2006). Stakeholders: Theory and practice. In Oxford University Press. OUP Oxford.
  12. Garzón Castrillón, Manuel Alfonso. (2021). The Concept of Corporate Governance. Revista Científica “Visión de Futuro,” 25(2), 178–194.
  13. General, Internal Market Directorate. (2002). Comparative Study of Corporate Governance Codes Relevant to The European Union and Its Member States. European Commission.
  14. Hansen, Jesper Lau. (2007). A Scandinavian Approach to Corporate Governance. Scandinavian Studies in Law, 50, 125–142.
  15. Iceland Chamber of Commerce, Nasdaq Iceland and SA Confederation of Icelandic Enterprise. (2021). Guidelines on Corporate Governance, 1–49. Iceland Chamber of Commerce, SA Confederation of Icelandic Enterprise, Nasdaq Iceland.
  16. Jensen, Michael C. (2001). 1. Value Maximization, Stakeholder Theory, and the Corporate Objective Function. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 14 (3), 3–25.
  17. Kent, Kevin M. (2009), Three Models of Corporate Governance from Developed Capital Markets.
  18. Kjærland, Frode, Haugdal, Ane Tolnes, Søndergaard, Anna, & Vågslid, Anne. (2020). Corporate Governance and Earnings Management In A Nordic Perspective: Evidence from The Oslo Stock Exchange. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 13 (11), 256.
  19. Lannoo, Karel. (1995). Corporate Governance In Europe: Report of A CEPS Working Party. Centre pour l’Etude des Politiques Publiques Europennes.
  20. Lekvall, Per, Gilson, Ronald J, Hansen, Jesper Lau, Lønfeldt, Carsten, Airaksinen, Manne, Berglund, Tom, von Weymarn, Tom, Knudsen, Gudmund, Norvik, Harald, & Skog, Rolf. (2014). The Nordic Corporate Governance Model. In The Nordic Corporate Governance Model, Per Lekvall, ed., SNS Förlag, Stockholm (No. 14–12).
  21. Mähönen, Jukka, & Johnsen, Guðrún. (2019). Law, Culture and Sustainability. In The Cambridge Handbook of Corporate Law, Corporate Governance and Sustainability (pp. 218–231). Cambridge University Press; (Doi.org/10.1017/9781108658386.022).
  22. Malline, Christine A. (2010), Corporate Governance, London: Oxford University Press.
  23. Naciri, Ahmed (Editor). (2008). Corporate Governance Around The World. In Routledge Co. (Vol. 1). Routledge Co.
  24. Nestor, Slipton & John K. Thompson (2000), "Corporate Governance Patterns in OECD Economies: Is Convergence Under Way?", Discussion Paper, Paris: OECD.
  25. Pasban, Mohammad Reza (1394 SH). Company Law (Volume 2). Tehran: SAMT.
  26. Schøning, Lena. (2017). Good Governance Tools: Cross-Pollination from Nordic Corporate Law. Arctic Review, 8 (0 SE-Original Articles), 160–173; (Doi.org/10.23865/arctic.v8.722).
  27. Securities market association, (2020).
  28. Seyyed Ahmadi Sajjadi, Seyed Ali (1388 SH). Agency Theory in the Corporate Governance System. Journal of Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Volume 39, Number 4.
  29. Shah, Neeta, Napier, Christopher J, & Holloway, R. (2017). The Cadbury Report 1992: Shared Vision and Beyond. In United Kingdom.
  30. Spisto, Michael Michele Paolo. (2006). Legal Aspects of Corporate Governance In The Republic of South Africa: Towards A Possible Model For Improved Stakeholder Relations Within The Corporation [University of The Witwatersrand Johannesburg South Africa].
  31. Taqipour, Bahram, Abbasi-Sarmadi, Mehdi, and Abedini, Hossein (1397 SH). Minority Rights in Joint Stock Companies based on the Corporate Governance System; A Comparative Study in Iranian and American Law. Journal of Islamic Law Research, Year 19, Number 2 (No. 48), 369-396.
  32. Taqipour, Bahram, and Abedini, Hossein (1398 SH). Legal System Approach to Key Indicators of Corporate Governance. Quarterly Journal of Private Law Studies, Volume 49, Number 3, 409-424.
  33. The Norwegian Code of Practice for Corporate, 1 (2014).
  34. The Swedish Corporate Governance Code, (2020).
  35. Thomsen, Steen, Rose, Caspar, & Kronborg, Dorte. (2016). Employee Representation and Board Size In The Nordic Countries. European Journal of Law and Economics, 42 (3), 471–490.
  36. Thomsen, Steen. (2014). Nordic Corporate Governance and Industrial Foundations 123.
  37. Thomsen, Steen. (2016 a). Nordic Corporate Governance Revisited. Nordic Journal of Business, 65(1), 4–12.
  38. Thomsen, Steen. (2016 b). The Nordic Corporate Governance Model. Management and Organization Review, 12 (1), 189–204.
  39. Waring, Kerrie, & Pierce, Chris. (2004). The Handbook of International Corporate Governance: A Definitive Guide. In Kogan Page Publishers.